Jean-Luc would you be so kind to send me the replay of flight 1 ? albervita@alice.it
thx
Alberto

yes of course, but the forum refuses because the file is too big. I put the replays in the cloud here :
https://drive.google.com/drive/folders ... mY60c0U1dzJe2?usp=sharing
say me if all ok to download them.

Now about the penalty 11 I got. Its a Nadeo bug because I entered clear ahead in the zone (at the begining you kept clear because Nadeo was OK but after you beared away Nadeo gave you the Right Of Way which is wrong).
"18.2 Giving Mark-Room
(b) .... If a boat is clear ahead when she reaches the zone, the boat clear astern at that moment shall thereafter give her mark-room."
Because I was slow (that is a sailing I may do) when you came inside me, you broke, IMO, rule 18.2(b) : you might give me the room to round the mark at the speed I was.

The previous 16.1 and 18.2.c are somewhat compensating.
The 11 was wrong and in any case since I refused to cancel it, the situation falls under art. 9.2 e) of SI.
This flight is 3-8 for UNT
Albervita

OK, I change the result in this direction.